On Edinburgh’s Royal Mile - Dunbar’s Close Garden

By Yvonne Michie Horn
This item appears on page 42 of the July 2019 issue.

Parterres edged with hedges. Photos by Yvonne Michie Horn

Hands down, Edinburgh’s Royal Mile wins as the city’s most visitor-trod street. And well it should be. To walk its length is to follow in the footsteps — most likely the carriage rumblings — of the kings and queens who for five centuries made the journey between the formidable castle-fortress that dominates the Old Town skyline to Holyrood Palace.

Since the 16th century, Holyrood has served as the Scots’ official royal residence. Today, Queen Elizabeth officially spends one summer week each year at the foot of the Royal Mile overseeing engagements and ceremonies.

Strolling the Royal Mile

With a guidebook in hand, it’s possible to identify vestiges of history from the 11th century onward, among them the 1477-built Moubray House, recognized as one of the city’s oldest buildings. At the beginning of the 18th century, Daniel Defoe, known best as the author of “Robinson Crusoe,” lived at Moubray House while editing the Edinburgh Courant.

Defoe described High Street, as it was then and still is locally known, as “the largest, longest, finest street not only in Britain but in the world.”

As I made my way down a noisy and people-crowded Royal Mile in June of 2018 (see my article “Maritime Jewels – Cruising the British Isles & Ireland” in the October 2018 issue), I wondered what Defoe would have to say about the influx of tourist-tacky that has elbowed its way into his “finest” — bagpiping buskers, shops touting touristy images of Scotland, tins of shortbread, racks of kilts, opportunities to buy an “authentic” family crest, etc. Well, there were those piles of cashmere sweaters and scarves that caught my eye and pocketbook.

Peonies in full bloom — Dunbar’s Close Garden, Edinburgh, Scotland.

Approaching the Holyrood end of the street, I spotted a sign on a wall of an unassuming passageway: “Dunbar’s Close Garden,” with an arrow pointing the way. Following the arrow’s direction through the passageway’s dark and cobbled interior, I stepped into a sunny, 17th-century garden of rustling leaves and birdsong.

Dunbar’s Close is one of some 80 medieval-era, narrow lanes, “closes,” that open off the Mile. The close I entered was named for one David Dunbar, a 17th-century Edinburgh writer who owned property near the passageway’s entrance, next to Canongate Kirk.

Unlike the tenement-crowded upper end of High Street, the Canongate lower area boasted fine houses set in elegant gardens. Dunbar’s Close Garden, sharing a stone wall on its west side with the kirk (church), offered a gracious example of those days.

Secluded hideaway

For a happy, quiet hour, I explored the garden’s series of symmetrical parterres, a favored design element of the time, each edged with a neatly clipped hedge and surrounded by a gravel path.

Old stone walls were softened with shrubbery (on one side I identified a stand of ancient yew), with recesses cut in for small flower beds and an occasional stone bench.

As I set off, I thought I was alone in the garden, until coming across a man sitting on one of those benches engrossed in his newspaper. Later on, a young couple wandered in to sit in another recess engrossed in each other. Otherwise, the garden was mine alone to enjoy.

Interiors of the parterres featured plant species of the time — lavender, iris and roses, salvias and peonies, beds of herbs. Mature trees, including fig and sycamore, provided areas of welcome shade. Midway through the garden, a woven-wood fence supporting an apple espalier divided the garden’s three-quarter-acre, rather narrow length.

Open to the public

A local found a quiet spot in the garden to read a newspaper.

It would be too much to expect that David Dunbar’s garden remained intact and cared for through the centuries. In 1977, The Mushroom Trust, a charity with its main focus the protection and enhancement of green spaces in and around Scotland, took on the abandoned and sadly overgrown site.

The trust commissioned landscape architect Seamus Filor with instructions to not attempt a re-creation of the garden but instead to design a plan true to its 17th-century roots. To do so, Filor took inspiration from old maps and a recent creation of a mid-17th-century garden at the Royal Botanic Gardens at Kew.

In 1978, the Trust turned over Dunbar’s Close Garden to the City of Edinburgh Council. A sign at the close’s entrance was installed and the public invited to step through and enjoy a serene respite. As did I.

Dunbar’s Close Garden is located at 137 Canongate (Canongate becomes High Street) in Edinburgh, Scotland. It opens to the public daily at 7 a.m., with closing times adjusted to the seasons.

Email Yvonne Michie Horn at yhorn@sonic.net. Also visit www.thetravelinggardener.com.


Dunbar’s Close Garden shares an old stone wall with the church next door.

Directional sign at the close's entry — Edinburgh, Scotland.